Tuesday, May 19, 2015

Literature as a Chain Letter Among Friends: How close is too close between reviewers and authors?


Literature as a Chain Letter Among Friends: On the Fantasy of Critical Distance

By Jonathon Sturgeonon


Over the weekend, New York Times Public Editor Margaret Sullivan lightly chided the editorial staff of the paper’s book review for a perceived imbalance in the way it chooses its reviewers. 
At issue is a question of intimacy or closeness. “How Close Is Too Close?” the article’s title asks (mirroring the oppressively Socratic form of the Review’s Bookends column). When a reviewer knows the book’s author, does this constitute a conflict of interest? … Read More

No comments: